Intervention is a function of the degree of similarity. Relativized minimality and the cartography of structural positions. From these tenets it follows that in italian any extraction from dp other than the subjects will cause a violation of relativized minimality, due to the intervention of the subject of dp also an aposition, thus yielding an account of the original generalization. The volume is a collection of 12 papers which focus on empirical and theoretical issues associated with syntactic phenomena falling under the rubric of relativized minimality rizzi 1990 or, in more recent terms, minimal link condition mlc, chomsky 1995. Careful comparison of ascrambling and overt whmovement in a language that shows both russian reveals that this seemingly paradoxical behavior can be captured effectively in a probegoal theory of scrambling that obeys a form of relativized minimality defined across feature classes, following rizzi 2004. On relativized minimality, memory and cuebased parsing. If so, the relativized minimality clause of the definition of antecedentgovernment is violated, because a typical potential governor, the whphrase in the spec cp, intervenes between the position. It turns out that longdistance crossing possibilities fully predict the local orderings entailed by rizzis leftperipheral template. As is evident, these same cases potentially favor the mlc, depending on whether some property of c can be shown to be involved, that attracts v but not i.
Project muse promotes the creation and dissemination of essential humanities and social science resources through collaboration with libraries, publishers, and scholars worldwide. Second, we propose a theory, based on a version of kaynes 1994 linear correspondence axiom, where fofc is an effect of the distribution of a movementtriggering feature in extended projections, subject to relativized minimality. Feature dissimilarities in the processing of german. Pdf it is argued that relativized minimality rm, rizzi 1990 and starke 2001, a. Relativized minimality, datives, and reflexive suffixes. All iwa sustained a single unilateral damage to their dominant hemisphere between 2 and 20 years m 9. Anagnostopoulou fox advanced syntax, spring 2007 weak islands and relativized minimality 1. The goal of this chapter is to provide a new, refined formal. In other words, minimality does not play a role in bounding theory, while it plays a crucial role in determining whether or not the ecp is violated. The fact that the rescuebypfdeletion analysis makes it possible to unify a number of previously unrelated phenomena should be taken as a.
The case of romance clitics johan rooryck indiana university 1. Similar considerations apply to the revision of relativized minimality proposed by baker and hale 1990. Forged from a partnership between a university press and a library, project muse is a trusted part of the academic and scholarly community it serves. In this work, we report a new interaction pattern among adverb classes in the context of movement and examine the implications of this pattern with respect to rizzis 1990, 2001 relativized minimality, chomskys minimal link condition, and ernsts factevent object calculus. The minimality condition is intended to exclude ambiguity of government, meaning that barriers created by i are barriers for government only, not for movement. Relativized minimality account boskovic 2001as account of the restrictions on the occurrence of the sp reading involves three major aspects. This new edition has been extensively updated throughout.
Introduction to government and binding theory blackwell. Romance languages in which the verb moves up to the agreement projection in infinitives also display enclitic ordering kayne 1991. The following diagram might help to make clear how the principle works. Pdf grammaticality judgements are the fundamental experimental source of generative linguistic theory. Pdf relativized minimality and the extended peeking. Ten iwa 3 female, 7 male and 20 nonbraindamaged adults as controls 11 female, 9 male participated in this study. These findings have been interpreted within the relativized minimality rm approach, according to which local relations cannot be established between two terms of. Download free pope shenouda books pdf software there. Minimality, the idea that government of an element can be blocked by an. A systematic comparison of the two principles, however, reveals that they are not necessarily equivalent, when the wider class of weak islands is taken into account. Before moving to siena, rizzi was a full professor at the university of geneva. This principle, known as relativized minimality, was introduced by rizzi 1990 as a way of accounting for locality conditions on movement. It starts from the widely shared assumption that there are two fundamentally different types of movement.
Discussions of a number of topics missing from or not paid due attention in the first edition have been integrated or expanded. Download introductiontogovernmentandbindingtheory ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub. Grammaticality judgements are the fundamental experimental source of generative linguistic theory. Rescue by pf deletion, traces as noninterveners, and the. Minimality, the idea that government of an element can be blocked by an intervening governor, is simple and intuitively appealing. This solution relies on the suggestion of torrego 1996 empirically supported here that the experiencer in these languages is an adjunct. Adverb classes and the nature of minimality springerlink.
In rare instances, a publisher has elected to have a zero moving wall, so their current issues are available. Introduction to government and binding theory available for download and read online in other f. Whyi did you wonder whether i bought the book ti b. Download pdf introduction to government and binding theory book full free.
The latest versions of adobe reader do not support viewing pdf files within firefox on mac os and if you are using a modern intel mac, there is no official plugin for viewing pdf files within the browser window. Ecp effects, xpbarriers and minimality barriers recall two types of ecp effects. If you dont know, but think youd like to, i would recommend reading each page, beginning at the front, until you come to the back. The moving wall represents the time period between the last issue available in jstor and the most recently published issue of a journal. Frontiers child relativized minimality and grammaticality. If you know what relativized minimality is, you already have read this book. The analysis predicts that, crosslinguistically, the option of. Introduction the subject matter of relativized minimality henceforth rm is the general theory of movement. Students can learn from this volume most of the major syntactic characteristics of english, while becoming ready. Intervention effects in grammar and language acquisition. Before moving to siena, rizzi was a full professor at the university of geneva rizzi is codirector of the journal rivista di grammatica generativa. Download fulltext pdf assessing sentence comprehension abilities. Jun 01, 2010 read relativizing minimality for amovement.
We explain this discrepancy using relativized minimality rm, rizzi 2004. They may be difficult to elicit, especially in some populations, but generally they inform us neatly about what the grammar licenses or, on the contrary, bans. Syntax, locality, intervention, relativized minimality, weak islands, relatives, language acquisition 1 a unitary approach to intervention effects intervention effects have been classically explored in formal syntax in connection with weakisland phenomena. Evidence from whquestion production and comprehension in greek aphasia. The article demonstrates that the rescuebypfdeletion account of the amelioration effect of island violations under ellipsis, originally noted by ross 1969, can be extended to account for the thattrace effect, including the adverb amelioration effect, and the lack of intervention effects with certain null arguments that are otherwise found. A general way to express both these restrictions is to claim that a moving element cannot move over the top of a like element. The pdfs posted here are updated daily, so we recommend bookmarking the pdfs instead of saving them locally or printing. The minimality analysis also applies to the cnpc of the nouncomplement type.
Lecture notes advanced syntax linguistics and philosophy. On the other hand, acceptability is multifactorial and therefore, unlike grammaticality judgement, can be quantified. Pdf minimality effects in childrens passives researchgate. Project muse a syntactic universal and its consequences. Download this pdf file the pdf file you selected should load here if your web browser has a pdf reader plugin installed for example, a recent version of adobe acrobat reader. The phenomenon of frozen scope in double object and sprayload constructions is shown to hold robustly across contexts, constructions, and quantifier types. Major trends in theoretical and applied linguistics 2. Relativized minimality linguistic inquiry monographs. Get your kindle here, or download a free kindle reading app. According to featural relativized minimality, the local relation between an extracted element and its trace is disrupted when it crosses an intervening element whose morphosyntactic featural specification matches the specification of the elements it separates. Since its first publication in 1991 liliane haegemans introduction to government and binding theory has become established as the most authoritative introduction to the principles and parameters approach to syntactic theory. Predictions from relativized minimality are borne out except for complex identity. At the back, you can close the book and say with some satisfaction there. This textbook shows a healthy and rare mix of recent and updated discussion of current syntactic theory and a detailed description of english syntax.
Rizzi is currently a full professor at the university of siena in italy. Three acceptability studies examined the role of lexical restriction and dlinking. This paper shows that bellettis 1988 and raposo and uriagerekas 1990 arguments against long distance nominative assignment in gb carry over to long distance agreement within the agreebased model chomsky 2000, 2001. The analysis predicts that, crosslinguistically, the option of raising across the experiencer is in. The scrambling paradox linguistic inquiry mit press journals. Pdf child relativized minimality and grammaticality judgement. Introduction throughout the romance languages, enclitic ordering in positive imperatives is obligatory. Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. The asymmetries classes of features local actions on phrases by heads. Absolutive constructions in brazilian portuguese and relativized.
Relativized minimality attempted to provide a unifying explanation for the island constraints see. If the inline pdf is not rendering correctly, you can download the pdf file here. We argue that these findings immediately follow from the way intervention and locality are computed, under the featural relativized minimality. Discussions of a number of topics missing from or not. Major structural changes include new chapters on functional heads and head movement and on relativized minimality. Pdf on relativized minimality, memory and cuebased parsing. If you would like more information about how to print, save, and work with pdfs, highwire press provides a helpful frequently asked questions about pdfs.
He studied at the scuola normale superiore, the university of pisa and the university of paris viii. Since its first publication in 1991 liliane haegemans introduction to government and binding theory has become established as the most authoritative introduction to the principles and parameters approach to. Absolutive constructions in brazilian portuguese and relativized minimality effects in childrens. Linguistic inquiry relativize minimality external argument maximal projection measure phrase. Minimality effects in syntax arthur stepanov, gisbert fanselow, ralf vogel the volume is a collection of 12 papers which focus on empirical and theoretical issues associated with syntactic phenomena falling under the rubric of relativized minimality rizzi 1990 or, in more recent terms, minimal link condition mlc, chomsky 1995. We interpret this selective effect in terms of a proper extension of relativized minimality, the principle of syntactic theory which expresses locality effects linked to.
Grammatical feature dissimilarities make relative clauses. This monograph presents an important extension of governmentbinding theory in syntax. Howi did you wonder whether i bought the book ti c. The resulting analysis exposes the distinct nature of strong and. In this article, i discuss the interaction of locality phenomena with the left periphery in italian as elaborated in rizzi 1997, 2001a, 2004b. It offers a new characterization of locality in the theory of government through a relativization of the minimality principle, and it explores the consequences of this approach for the empty category principle and the.
The volume is a collection of 12 papers which focus on empirical and theoretical issues associated with syntactic phenomena falling under the rubric of relativized minimality rizzi 1990 or, in more recent terms, minimal link condition mlc, chom. Relativized minimality effects the handbook of contemporary. This analysis is based on the view that the experiencer in these languages is an adjunct. Relativized minimality is a theory of structural intervention. Pdf comprehension asymmetries in language acquisition. Abstract according to featural relativized minimality, the local relation between an extracted element and its trace is disrupted when it crosses an intervening element whose morphosyntactic featural specification matches the specification of the elements it separates. Nevertheless, frozen scope is not absolute, holding only between two objects but not between an object and a. A test for relativized minimality article pdf available september 2012 with 50 reads. Luigi rizzi born june 3, 1952 in genoa is an italian linguist. The scrambling paradox linguistic inquiry mit press. Major structural changes include new chapters on functional heads and head movement and on. Featural relativized minimality while in previous systems the contrast between 2 and 3 was addressed by assuming that whelements like which problem can use nonlocal devices connecting them to their traces rizzi, 1990 assumed the possibility of a nonlocal binding.
Second, the proposed algorithm yields a novel account of the class of island phenomena. Major trends in theoretical and applied linguistics volume 2 pp. Minimality effects in syntax by arthur stepanov overdrive. The relativized minimality approach to adependencies friedmann et al. The pdf file you selected should load here if your web browser has a pdf reader plugin installed for example, a recent version of adobe acrobat reader if you would like more information about how to print, save, and work with pdfs, highwire press provides a helpful frequently asked questions about pdfs alternatively, you can download the pdf file directly to your computer, from where it. Minimality effects in syntax arthur stepanov, gisbert. Luigi rizzi born june 3, 1952 in genoa is an italian linguist rizzi is currently a full professor at the university of siena in italy. Indeed, the mlc derives two of the main consequences of relativized minimality, namely whislands and superraising. It offers a new characterization of locality in the theory of government through a relativization of the minimality principle, and it explores the consequences of this.
138 1229 1632 969 544 1273 801 1112 841 544 406 1025 820 378 85 232 935 649 1010 141 787 612 273 665 708 306 1624 186 874 254 1083 781 501 309 595